This is a series of posts about the music I play while writing. This time I’m up to Don McLean and his song, Vincent. Released in 1971 on McLean’s album AmericanPie and as a single in 1972 it quickly went to number 2 on the Easy Listening chart and rank number 94 for 1972.
Anyone who was a teen in the 70’s has heard and likely loves McLean’s songs like Vincent, and American Pie. I had a number of friends who had memorized American Pie and would endlessly discuss the meanings in the song. I liked it, but not as much as my friends.
Vincent is one of those songs that I didn’t really appreciate as a teenager. I knew it was a great song, but it didn’t really speak to me that much. It wasn’t until I was much older that I began to understand that McLean was describing a real person with real struggles. It wasn’t until after I’d seen a video of Leonard Nimoy’s one play play Vincent I did really begin to appreciate who Vincent van Gogh was and is to the world of art.
Van Gogh was a troubled mind but a great artist. The more you learn about him, the sadder the story becomes.
The brilliance of McLean’s song is to put into words just exactly the struggles van Gogh had. McLean doesn’t dance around the subject with this line in the chorus, “And how you suffered for your sanity.” It doesn’t get plainer than that. McLean also pulls in the details of van Gogh’s paintings with lines like, “Paint your palette blue and grey” and “Flaming flowers that brightly blaze.” I suggest listening to this song while viewing van Gogh’s art. It will make more sense then.
In fact, McLean states that he wrote this song after reading a book about van Gogh and while looking at the painting, Starry Night.
My wife and I once bought a jigsaw puzzle version of Starry Night. I think it was around 2,000 pieces and it took us four or five months to put it together. It was the most difficult puzzle we’ve ever done. Which is a metaphor for van Gogh’s life – complicated and difficult.
In the fall of 2023 Heather and I took a cruise in the Mediterranean and had the opportunity to visit the village of Saint-Remy where the Saint-Paul Asylum is. That is where van Gogh spent a year as a patient. This is where he painted Starry Night and other works. The old monastery with the asylum is now a museum and a draw for tourists and artist alike. Walk from the bus stop by the building, you’ll encounter many painters working while looking at the places van Gogh painted more than a century before.
This song ends up on my playlist because it is a story about a struggling artist and because of the evocative way McLean manages to tell the story. It’s a well told story and the kind of writing I’d like to imitate.