This is a series of posts about the music I play while writing.
The next on the play list is Gordon Lightfoot’s “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.”
I first heard this song when I was 16 and working in the kitchen of a convalescent hospital as a dishwasher. It immediately resonated with me and the song became an instant favorite of mine. It’s the story, the melancholy melody and the feeling the lyrics leave behind. There is poetry that Lightfoot uses to stitch the story and images together. Lines like, “In the rooms of her ice-water mansion,” and “The wind in the wires made a tattle-tale sound,” build not only the feeling of the song, but also the image of what it may have been like to be on the water that night when the Edmund Fitzgerald went down.
The song is based on a real event. SS Edmund Fitzgerald was a freighter on the Great Lakes that hauled iron ore from the mines to the mills. On the evening of November 10, 1975, the ship sank and all 29 on board died. Lightfoot read a magazine article about the sinking and was inspired to write the song.
Lightfoot’s genus here is just telling the story and doing the music he does best. His lyrics are simple, yet evocative and by the time the song ends the listener has a good idea what happened that night. We feel the frustration of the searchers and grief of the families left behind. Lightfoot did take a number of artistic liberties with some facts: We can’t really know what the cook said, the name of the church is wrong and it wasn’t an “old musty hall.” Yet, his speculation on why the ship sank is in line with the best theories of why the Edmund Fitzgerald sank.
The exact cause of the sinking isn’t known, even to this day all we have are theories and contributing factors. The Edmund Fitzgerald may have been overloaded for the weather conditions, navigation and communication equipment could have been better, possibly they should have waited a day before sailing and it’s possible that could have just been a rouge wave that broke the ship’s back. We’ll never know. Maritime rules on the Great Lakes were changed as a result of the sinking and today our GPS navigation, weather forecasting, tighter shipping regulations, and better communications equipment would likely prevent a sinking like the Edmund Fitzgerald.
Over the years, I’ve only heard the song on the radio a handful of times. The full version is over six minutes long and radio stations don’t like to play anything that long as it reduces the time available for commercials. With streaming music services, that’s not a problem anymore and the song is now on my play list as it helps create a contemplative mood in my head and triggers my story telling mind.